Randy and Paula are responsible for this American Idol disaster

(left) I hope your happy dummy, now we wont hear the gorgeous Melissa McGhee ever again. In an era of 'pop' star females McGhee could have been a Pat Benetar, and thats a pretty darn rare thing.









--(DIRECTLY above) She' a complete dolt,
but get a load of those sandbags!



Dear lord! What are people watching? Tonight on American Idol one of the most talented people by far was voted off, and some of the worst remained. The beautiful and talented Melissa McGhee was the first of the top twelve to be put down by a voting public that clearly is blind, deaf, and or dumb. In five season of this program McGhee’s version of Heart’s ‘what about love’ is one of the finest female performances in Idol’s history. Reaming contestant Kevin Covais is miserable singers in American Idol, but somehow managed to NOT be in the bottom three Wednesday night. Who is voting? Bucky Covington, and Kellie Pickler also lack a serious amount of singing talent. Lets face it, Pickler’s nice looking, but she can’t really carry a tune all that well, and Covington should be doing karaoke in a Honkey tonk bar somewhere.

So who’s to blame for this injustice? Look no further than Randy Jackson and Paula Abdual. Like it or lump it, people listen to all of the judges and when only one of them is being realistic, it hurts the chances for the public to make an intelligent decision. Randy and Paula have been blowing smoke up Kevins tail since day one for no good reason. Had they been real and dogged Covais a bit like Simon has, we wound not have said goodbye to one of the more talented contestants tonight. The damage is done, I just hope that Randy and Paula realize how they impacted one of the most talented contestants in favor of what is a complete joke in Kevin, and Bucky. It doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things because Chris is so much better than anyone who has ever been on Idol before, but it does rob us of a better competition down the stretch.